March Menu
Please note: We restock every Thursday, so availability may change as the weekend goes on. Due to the multi-day process of our ‘witches and novelties, it isn’t possible to restock during our sales weekend. We appreciate your understanding!
Event/off-site menus vary. Check our social media for the latest info!
Ice Cream
‘Witches
Core - $8
Ursula
Vanilla Ice Cream + Rainbow Sprinkles + Salted Brownie
Thin Mint Elphaba
Thin Mint Ice Cream + Salted Mint Brownie
Gideon
Vanilla Ice Cream + Chocolate-Covered Pretzels + Peanut Butter Layer + Peanut Butter Chip Brownie
Tara
Miso Brown Sugar Ice Cream + Milk Chocolate Chip Blondie
Cruella (v+/gf)
Cookies & Cream ‘Scream’ + Oreo Brownie
Seasonal - $8
Becky
Lemon Buttermilk Ice Cream + Gooey Butter Cake
Persephone
Pomegranate Chocolate Chip Ice Cream + Black Cocoa Brownie + Oat Rose Crumble
Magica de Spell
Cereal Milk Ice Cream + Cocoa Rice Crispy Treat
Suliman (v+/gf)
Salted Caramel ‘Scream’ + Fudgy Brownie
Hexes
Half-pound packs of trimmed edges from our ice cream sandwiches - $8
Waffles
Waffles - $12
Classic Peanut Taco
Classic Waffle + Vanilla Ice Cream + Dark Chocolate Shell + Peanuts
Banana Pudding Taco
Classic Waffle + Banana Pudding Ice Cream + Banana Shell + Nilla Wafers + Salted Caramel Brittle
Halo-Halo Queen Cone
Coconut Waffle + Mango Ice Cream + Ube Shell + Salted Caramel Brittle + Crispy Rice + Toasted Coconut
Sundae
Salted Malted Milk & Cookies - $10
Salted Malted Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Ice Cream + Blackberry Swirl + Oreos + Whipped Cream + Chocolate Drizzle
Pints & Cups
Pints - $12
Vanilla
Espresso Cookie Butter
Croissundae (caramel raspberry croissant)
Chocolate S’mores
Cocoa Orange Blondie
Brownie Batter Cookie Dough
Chocolate Peanut Butter Brownie
Red Velvet
Cinnamon Toast Crunch Cereal Milk
Breakfast at Sugarwitch (espresso croissant maple caramel)
Cinnamon Raisin Oatmeal Cookie (v+/gf)
Chocolate Raspberry Sorbet (v+/gf)
Cups - $5-7
Vanilla Sprinkle (gf)
Chocolate Cookie Crunch (sugar-free)
Pup Cups* - $4
*Proceeds support the Humane Society of Missouri
Drinks
Coffee
Drip - $3/3.5
Cafe au Lait - $3.5/4
Classic Cold Brew - $5
Nitro Cold Brew - $5.5
Espresso - $2.75
Americano - $4
Latte - $4.5/5
Cappuccino - $4
Espresso con Panna - $3.5
House Syrups:
Vanilla, Caramel, Chocolate, Real Maple Syrup, Lavender, Miso Brown Sugar
Milk Options:
Whole Milk, Oat Milk, Almond Milk
Drink Toppings: (+$1)
Cream Cheese Foam, Marshmallow Fluff
Tea & Beyond
feat. Big Heart Tea & River’s Remedies
Chai Latte - $5/5..5
Tiramisu Chai - $6
Make it dirty + espresso ($1)
Matcha Latte - $5.5/6
London Fog - $5/5.5
Hot Tea - $4
Chamomile Mint (herbal)
Spicy Pumpkin (black)
Apple Sauce - $4
River’s Remedies herbal tea shaken with blackberry thyme syrup & apple juice (hot or cold)
Specials
Raspberry Matcha - $6
Fresh Raspberry Sauce + Matcha Latte + Freeze Dried Raspberry
Tiramisu Cold Brew - $7
Cold Brew + Espresso Vanilla Syrup + Mascarpone Foam + Rum Caramel + Cocoa Powder + Ladyfingers (contains egg & wheat)
Orange White Chocolate Mocha - $6.5
White Chocolate Orange Blossom Sauce + Marigold Orange Sugar
Vietnamese Egg Cream - $7
Extra-Strong Chicory Brown Sugar Latte + Egg Custard Cream + Cinnamon
Frozen
Ice Cream Cube Flavors:
Vanilla // Vegan Vanilla // Chocolate // Cherry Blossom
Affogato - $5
Choice of Ice Cream + Double Espresso
Cold Brew Float - $8
Nitro Cold Brew + Choice of Ice Cream + Choice of Syrup + Whip Cream
Matcha Float - $8
Big Heart Matcha + Cream Soda + Choice of Ice Cream + Whip Cream
Soda Float - $6
Choice of Excel Soda + Choice of Ice Cream + Whip Cream
Bottled
Topo Chico - $2
Excel Soda - $3
v+ = vegan; df = dairy-free; gf = gluten-free
Equipment is shared, please use your best judgment and consume at your own risk.